Does the Bible Teach “Bible Alone”?
Many Christians have been taught that the Bible alone is the foundation of Christianity. Also known as sola scriptura, this is a false doctrine emanating from the Catholic monk Martin Luther. Luther began what he thought was a reformation, but in reality was a revolution. The idea sounds reasonable: if God gave us His Word, shouldn’t the Word be the only authority? But an honest reading of Scripture reveals something surprising.
The Bible never teaches the doctrine of the Bible alone. In fact, it quietly assumes the opposite.
Near the end of John’s Gospel, we are told that not everything Jesus said or did was written down (John 21:25). Christianity began as a preached faith before it was ever a written one. The apostles taught by speaking, and Christians were commanded to preserve those teachings — not only in writing, but also in memory and practice (1 Cor 11:2; 1 Pet 1:25).
From the very beginning, Christianity was Scripture and living teaching together.
The Authority Christ Left Behind
The New Testament does not present Jesus handing His followers a book and telling them to interpret it.
Instead, He establishes a Church and gives it His authority.
He gives the apostles power to bind and loose (Mt 16:13-20; 18:18).
He declares that whoever hears them hears Him (Lk 10:16).
He promises this Church will endure until the end of time (Mt 16:18; Mt 28:19-20; Jn 14:16).
Scripture states something crucial: Christians must hold fast to both written and oral teaching (2 Thess 2:15; 3:6).
The Bible even warns that its writings can be difficult to interpret (2 Pet 3:15-16) and identifies the Church — not the individual believer — as the pillar and foundation of truth (1 Tim 3:15).
In other words, the Bible points to an interpreter.
Why “Bible Alone” Cannot Work
Every authoritative text requires an authoritative interpreter.
Without one, the text does not unite — it divides.
Consider the U.S. Constitution. The founders did not leave a document alone; they created the Supreme Court to interpret it. Without a living authority, every citizen would become his own court, and the law would fragment.
If human lawmakers understood this, it would be strange to believe God left Christianity governed by a book without a living authority to guard its meaning.
Yet that is exactly what Sola Scriptura requires.
The Historical Reality of Early Christianity
For the first generations of Christians, there was no New Testament to read.
Believers gathered in homes, listened to apostolic preaching, and heard portions of letters and Gospels as they circulated. Only centuries later did the Church formally recognize which writings were inspired and assemble the Bible.
This creates a simple historical fact:
If you trust the Bible, you already trust the authority that identified it.
The same Church that preserved the books preserved the faith they taught.
The Practical Consequence
If the Bible alone were self-interpreting, Christians reading the same text should reach the same conclusions.
Instead, thousands of conflicting doctrines exist — all claiming biblical support.
The issue is not whether Scripture is true.
The issue is who has the authority to interpret it.
Christianity ultimately rests on one question:
Did Christ leave a book alone, or a Church that teaches with His authority?
The Real Question Behind Every Debate
Every disagreement about Catholicism ultimately returns to the same foundation: authority.
Once that question is answered, the rest of Christianity stops looking confusing and starts fitting together.
Catholics Are Wrong… Says Who? explains the single-issue step by step, using simple reasoning and Scripture itself.
Begin here → https://www.catholicsarewrong.com
Listen to Bishop Robert Barron explain a practical way to read the Bible
Bishop Barron on How to Read the Bible
Another part of a video series from Wordonfire.org. Bishop Barron will be commenting on subjects from modern day culture. For more visit http://www.wordonfire.org/
Resources for the Bible Alone doctrine
You must be logged in to post a comment.